It’s weird how we find some people attractive and others not. For me Matt Smith is one I don’t find attractive when EVERYONE ELSE DOES.
I’ve only found Matt Smith attractive in two photos so I’m there with you but I guess it really depends on a lot of factors. The photos of Andrew Scott that I’ve liked are so far removed from any character I’ve seen him play so maybe that’s why they hit me so well. Same with Matt Smith. He’s so pretty when he’s put together. I dislike all his hipster clothes. So I dunno.